Sword Art Online: Alicization - War of Underworld is the second part of the Alicization arc of the story, which is based upon the light novel series. It is 23 episodes long and takes place a few months after the end of the last season. Kirito is in a virtual world, which he had grown up in. One of his childhood friends has just gone, while the other has returned. The big bad is down, at the cost of Kirito himself, who is now a vegetable, being looked after by Alice.
The last season of Alicization finished on a cliffhanger and War of Underworld picks up after it. We see that Kirito has now fallen into a comatose state in a wheelchair, unable to look after himself. Alice is with him, and they are at first living peacefully in a secluded village (or as peacefully as you can when the whole village hates you). The peace is soon shattered as the real world and this virtual world clashes. In the real world, mercenaries have arrived to take the “fluctlight” of Alice, and naturally, circumstances dictate that they dive into this world.
As a result, in the virtual world, the world of humans and the world of the dark territory across the mountains clash together in a big battle. The dark territory forces are the usual fantasy monsters such as goblins and orcs, including dark mages and knights. Most of them have a penchant for violence and are just happy to invade, fight and kill. What little hope and respectful characters within the dark territory are soon gone, which is a shame.
The ensuing battle forces Alice to go back to the other Integrity Knights, who are holding out and responsible for pushing back against the invasion. At its core, the plot is very simple, and a lot of the episodes are dragged out with the flashy effects of battles. There are a lot of flashbacks, and Kirito, even in his comatose state, is of course the center of all attention and somehow manages to convince new characters that they like him. The anime tends to rely too heavily on the jargon of its sci-fi aspect, which makes it feel like it is trying too hard to justify that everything makes sense. It also leans towards making antagonists that are unlikable not because being well designed, but because they are creepy.
Sword Art Online has always tried to take itself too seriously, and has extremely cringeworthy dialogue and story developments, as well as being too melodramatic and naïve at the same time. It’s gotten progressively worse with every story arc, and we see it in spades during this season. It handwaves all the technical complexities of some of its developments. It tries very hard to justify why things have happened the way they were but comes off as trying too hard in the process. Gigantic exposition dumps are not the best way to tell a story. Big speeches that convinces selfish random people to help in some farfetched unbelievable conflict is not cringeworthy.
Kirito is out for most of the season, but he still takes a huge chunk of the focus. Every single character has some sort of obsession with him, whether that is his harem, or the villainous characters. Perhaps the worst part is how this season arbitrarily brings back as many characters as it possibly can from previous seasons. It’s just so formulaic and predictable, and cringey, when the power of friendship allows these characters to just break rules or common sense and arrives just in the nick of time to help protect everything.
Perhaps the most annoying thing is even the villains are not immune from this. They just had to have crossed paths with Kirito before and developed an obsession about him. It stretches the belief that these coincidences could be just that, coincidences. Rather it feels forced when someone from the very early days of Sword Art Online and Aincrad, had crossed paths with Kirito, and those encounters were so memorable, that it kept fueling them until this very day. Of course, we are constantly waiting for Kirito’s return but not because you are eagerly anticipating it, but more so just so it can be over and done with, so that it can move on.
Even then it’s not enough because when Kirito comes out, the anime goes all in on having him be the savior and the only hero that this world ever needs. It’s kind of annoying when the anime takes the easy way out, and calls upon the power of friendship, the power of love, and all that kind of thing so that Kirito can get the power he needs to overcome the villain (who has problems of his own with how he managed to attain his immense power). It just feels like the author was making things up as he goes along and magics things to the way it is required to close off the story. Despite all the buildup, the battle ensuring after Kirito’s return is over in an episode. It makes you question whether it was worth waiting all that time beforehand.
The season finale wraps everything up both slowly and quickly at the same time. When Kirito awakes and kicks the villain out, there is still quite a bit of the story left. The anime blurs the line between real life and VR, to the point where VR is still a computer program at the end of the day, and yet it has all these possibilities and the tiniest amount of detail already mapped out, to the point it feels implausible. After the VR world is saved, there are many plot points of the real-life situation still ongoing, but with the big climax and reveal done, it’s like a drag.
It loses the plot right at the end though. Again, the anime is trying to be this serious philosophical thing but ends up becoming hyper exaggerated and melodramatic. It’s one implausible event after another, and the final episode was really icing on the cake. Literally, it is Sword Art Online… in space, which feels so lazy and stupid. Of course, it teases that Kirito will return, but the question is, do we really need more of him?
Overall, Sword Art Online: Alicization - War of Underworld is a mediocre anime. It is a continuation of the Alicization arc, which had potential, but it quickly squandered it with its generic premise and developments, overreliance on nonsensical power ups of the characters, and just plain weird characters who cross the line to being creepy rather than iconic and cool. The series feels like it has run its course, and is just aimless, not knowing where it wants to go.
---------------------------------------------
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases)