My Next Life as a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom! X is the second season based upon the light novel series. It’s 12 episodes long again plus an OVA. The premise was that when Catarina was young, she hit her head and recovered all the memories of her past life in Japan. Now in this fantasy world which she realized was based upon a visual novel that she had played, she was originally destined to have a bad ending no matter what. However, at the end of the last season, it was fully confirmed (even though it was obvious before) that she had avoided that fate, and that everything from now on will be brand new to her.
Given that the premise is now over, the anime really isn’t much more than a fantasy slice of life. Catarina herself is popular and has gathered quite a harem of lovers and followers. Although given how much she was an otaku in her past life, she is clueless and oblivious to the feelings that everyone else has for her. Catarina’s charms come from breaking from the stereotype of nobility in that world.
Catarina had moved up a year in the academy and… that’s basically it. She is continuing on with her school life, from tending to her own farm, to checking out and participating in culture festivals. What little uniqueness it had from its premise is almost completely gone. She recalls elements of that visual novel from time to time, but it doesn’t significantly influence or is required by the plot.
You can’t deny that the plot doesn’t progress. Catarina is nearing the end of her time at the academy and with that, the others are starting to win over Catarina to their side. At the forefront is Prince George, the official fiancé of Catarina. Although everyone else that’s smitten with Catarina doesn’t make it easy. With that said, Catarina’s romantic maturity gets a big push.
Despite Catarina starting to get real life experience with romance, the plot is still thin. This season has frequent flashbacks to when Catarina was young. It seems to have the characters remembering or reminiscing about an event or another, and it makes you wonder perhaps the first season (and the earlier parts of the story) went through Catarina’s childhood too quickly.
There are a few plot arcs in the season where it takes multiple episodes. This wasn’t something we had seen in the first season, and it is welcomed here, allowing for some deeper interactions and feeling less episodic. While none of the events are significant or too consequential, they have the effect of some of the other characters becoming a bit more serious. They don’t want status quo anymore and want to be the one that Catarina chooses.
Unfortunately, the whole season is Catarina with her harem, going on with her life, with a little bit of kidnapping here and there. It isn’t enough as a hook to keep you watching. It can be too predictable, and Catarina as the clueless character can only stick for so long. It’s not a surprise when towards the end, it comes back to its original premise, feeling like it was a little bit desperate.
The OVA is like a recap episode, where each of the characters reminiscent about their first meeting with Catarina. It tells it from their perspective (reusing a lot of animation) and has their voiceover of what was running through their heads at the time. Despite the repetitive nature of it, there are some minor new nuggets of information and context, and it is an OVA that is perfect to watch right before the start of the second season as a refresher.
Overall, My Next Life as a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom! X, cannot even be classified as more of the same. Rather, it feels like something that kept going even though it had resolved its original mystery. It’s not terrible, but just feels uninspired and lacking an objective, even if it doesn’t know what it wants to do. The reveal at the end that promises more just makes you roll your eyes.
---------------------------------------------
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases)